Eighteen Months of Low Carb
Dietitian’s organisations frequently criticise low carbohydrate diets for not being proven safe in the long term. Poorly controlled diabetes (where blood glucose is higher than for people without diabetes) on the other hand, has been proven extremely unsafe in the medium to long-term. For people with diabetes, a restricted-carbohydrate diet is almost certain to lower blood glucose and remove or eliminate medications. This one ‘radical’ diet change can hardly fail to alleviate most of the ill effects of diabetes, medicinal side effects and both of their risks. Clearly, the ‘unknown risk’ of the low carbohydrate diet in the long term can be weighed against the near certain risks of diabetes. Otherwise, blindness, amputation, cardiovascular disease, dialysis from kidney failure and a shortened lifespan will nearly always be the end result.
I have now passed eighteen months on a low carbohydrate diet. That means I have exceeded the 74 weeks of the ‘best’ vegan diet study by Barnard. I thought it was time to wrap up the comparison and reflect on my health progress to see where my health journey could now go. That is the focus of this post.
Let’s get straight into that with an update to my HbA1c chart.
At the end of August, I was a little disappointed. The downward trend ceased and my result was actually 0.1% higher than in May. This was mitigated by the fact that the result is only accurate to one decimal place anyway and the later result in December came in again at 5.6%. All these results are still in the non-diabetic range. I still take 500mg of metformin as this remains beneficial to further recovery despite having non-diabetic blood glucose. That can be compared with 2000mg of metformin, Januvia and Diamicron before low carb.
Unlike the conventional and vegan diets in the trial, my blood glucose has stabilised and not led to an increasing HbA1c after three to six months that sustains and increases medications. Compared to HbA1c population statistics, it is about four standard deviations lower than the vegan diet and that is maintained on a minimum amount of metformin- unlike the more heavily medicated study participants.
Finally, my ending HbA1C is about ten standard deviations less than the vegan study statistics. Statistically, it is practically impossible for any of the 49 vegan (or 50 conventional diabetes diet) participants to have achieved a similar result.
Long-Term HbA1c & Glucose Control
In the context of my long-term results, the last eighteen months of a low carbohydrate diet since month 31 on this chart, have been an unqualified success. I have had non-diabetic blood glucose for fifteen months, and even non-pre-diabetic blood glucose for at least 6 months.
It is important to realise that HbA1c is really only an average. Large fluctuations up and down can still give a good average but have the considerable risk of complications due to glycaemic variability. My blood glucose measurements have a standard deviation of an excellent 0.8 mmol/l and the tight glucose control that a low carbohydrate diet gives can be seen below. I have a normal non-diabetic HbA1c with low glycaemic variability. My blood glucose measurements were 98% within target showing tightly controlled blood glucose. Such is the efficacy of carbohydrate restriction for diabetes.
You can also see the effect of one inadvertent meal which included carbohydrates at my daughter’s graduation function. Refined carbohydrates are insidiously a part of our food supply and no one is perfect!
My Overall Health
Unfortunately, with very high blood glucose, I had just about every bad effect from diabetes that researchers have shown. So how is my health after eighteen months on a ‘fad’ diet of unprocessed foods low in refined carbohydrates and no ‘healthy’ whole grains?
- My total and LDL (‘bad’) cholesterol is about the same despite having increased my saturated fat intake greatly
- My HDL (good) cholesterol is up by about 40% and triglycerides are down by about 33% meaning that my ratio of triglycerides to HDL more than halved! The ratio of triglycerides to HDL is an important predictor of coronary disease.
- My liver function tests have normalised. This indicates remission of a fatty liver which is common in people with type 2 diabetes.
- My fasting insulin has had its lowest reading ever of 12 mIU/L (compared to 26 previously) and is in the normal range for the population and it coincided with a fasting glucose of 5.3 mmol/l. This is an indication of improved insulin resistance.
- I have control of my appetite and eating and can easily fast 16:8 or 23:1.
- My neuropathy (tingling and coldness in my toes) has reversed.
- My long-distance vision deterioration has reversed with lower blood glucose.
- My balance, memory & cognition have returned to what they were.
- I no longer have chronic bacterial and fungal infections. Only one cold in the past 18 months compared to constant illness in the times preceding.
- Retinal scans and analysis by specialists confirm no further deterioration in my vision from retinopathy.
- My kidney function is no longer abnormal.
- Episodes of gout are less frequent and less severe.
- My blood pressure is an excellent 117/74 despite adding ample salt to my food.
- I don’t have irritable bowel symptoms anymore. Among other discomforts, I was prone to unexplained and fairly frequent bouts of diarrhoea. My energy levels are good and I rarely feel bloated and my ‘gas’ production is negligible.
- My weight loss is 16 Kg and importantly my neckline and waist have shrunk. I have moved from obese to just overweight.
- I no longer have depression from having diabetes.
But not everything is the same. I do have one negative. I am more prone to constipation which I almost never suffered from before. This is almost always a problem if I do not hydrate properly. Looking at the list above, I sure can live with that!
It is undeniable that my health is vastly improved. My doctor is extremely pleased, I am extremely pleased and my family is extremely pleased.
Social Effects & Adherence
Quite bizarrely, the Dietitian’s Association of Australia cited (without evidence) that the low carb diet should not be used for diabetes because the health of other family members could be impacted. Would they make that comment for a coeliac? Nonetheless, I can report that when we have meals, the family generally eats the potatoes or carbohydrates and I have a different vegetable. If only I could get my children to avoid processed foods, skip the fries and stop asking for sugary drinks completely like I do! It seems that is even beyond my powers as a role model. However, because of my eating requirements and awareness, we have less refined carbohydrates and processed foods and my children have reduced their sugar intake. Maybe they meant that they didn’t want anyone’s health to improve?
When I go out to eat, I rarely have a problem finding something. If there are carbohydrates, I usually can get another vegetable substituted.
This is otherwise an unremarkable non-issue.
Measuring My Metabolism
In late September, I had my metabolism measured by Metabolic Health Solutions (MHS). In full disclosure, this was done for me at no cost. I had not understood before how metabolism, weight loss and diabetes tied together. Now I think I do!
My testing showed that my Resting Metabolic Rate (RMR) was 2145 kcal which is towards the top end for my age and body. That is good. It explains that I have the metabolism to potentially lose weight without vigorous exercise. My efficiency (FEO2) was 17.3% confirming that I am no athlete as it would be optimal if less than 15!
Very surprisingly, the test showed that my fuel mix was 24.7% from fat and 75.3% from carbohydrate. This surprised me as I thought that, being on a low carb diet, I would automatically be a good fat burner! Ideally, this should be almost opposite with 80% fat burning and 20% carb burning.
It seems my metabolism is more than happy burning carbohydrates from protein. It does explain why I generally have had trouble losing weight and still have trouble. Clearly, if one is a good fat burner and does not eat a lot of fat then one will burn body fat. Being a carb burner fully explains why, when I went on a slightly higher fat moderate protein diet, I stalled. Even though it was low carb, my body was still getting most of its energy by making glucose from protein.
Solutions for me include some longer fasts, a more ketogenic diet to encourage fat metabolism, and exercise.
Since that testing (and to be transparent as my blog is non-commercial) I have begun working with MHS because I am impressed with how this information can inform your weight loss and metabolic health strategy. The world has a lot of metabolically sick people.
Where to From Here?
It is still my aim to achieve an HbA1c of 5.1% or below. As I indicated in my last post, control theory would indicate that I am unlikely to achieve that on the current trajectory. The steady progression downwards has arrested and I am about one standard deviation from the target. I do want to lose further (fat) weight. I must change my approach or it seems I will always be above the setpoint or take a very long time to reach it. My sleep patterns are pretty good and my diet is working well. I am still doing only a little exercise. Here are some options.
A Ketogenic Diet
Presently my diet has quite a bit of protein in it. This does not raise my blood glucose as carbohydrates do but it keeps me out of ketosis a lot of the time. By operating more deeply in ketosis, my blood glucose would fall markedly more and I would likely achieve my 5.1% HbA1c. That means a higher fat diet. If I limit my protein I will also have reduced capacity to burn carbs (presuming I can spare muscle) and this may help me become a better fat burner.
I enjoy the higher protein low carbohydrate diet. I do not see a ketogenic diet as a long-term option for me since it more difficult to get sufficient nutrient density on a high-fat diet- but this might be something I do for a while if it helps me to become a better fat burner.
Some Longer Fasting
Most days I fast 16:8 by skipping breakfast. By extending this I can cause my metabolism to use my own body fat since while fasting it will not have carbohydrates, fat or protein from diet and should prefer to use my own body fat. As a 75% glucose burner, I need to be careful that my body does not decide to obtain glucose by catabolising muscle until I can change that.
I do not exercise much and have exercised little over the 18 months. Among other things, I wanted to see how far I could go with diet and did not want to confound diet and exercise. By building more muscle and doing high-intensity exercise I should be able to deplete my glycogen more easily and frequently, leading to a reduction in average blood glucose, as well as increasing my insulin sensitivity. High-intensity exercise will also be helpful, combined with fasting or a keto diet to reduce muscle loss, and help me to become a better fat burner.
To be honest, I have never been a marathon runner and likely never will be, so part of my challenge is to find the exercise that I will enjoy.
Having some real numbers from metabolic health testing has allowed me to focus on what I can do to improve my metabolic health. I am now more motivated to exercise and then be re-tested to see how I have improved.
A Note for Vegans
Sorry, but in my case, it was no contest. A vegan diet can (without question) improve your health if you are obese and have diabetes mainly by its calorie restriction, but Barnard’s study compared with my journey shows that it is neither as sustainable nor as optimal for me as carbohydrate restriction when compared against the study people. I went the distance of 78 weeks versus the study’s 74 weeks and it is “Game Over”.
Final Word to Dietetic Associations
Shouldn’t I be dead by now from the ‘fad’ diet? In fact, if I had listened to you I might have been well on my way to dialysis or amputation. I think you need to get over your prejudice against low carbohydrate and higher fat diets. After all, despite some health-washing to make the much-lauded Mediterranean Diet appear as a low-fat diet- it is actually also a high-fat diet.
It is without question for me or my doctor that a low carbohydrate approach has led me to vastly improved health and a reversal of diabetes. If you have any real semblance of taking an evidence-based approach, that should also be obvious to you. You say that your members deliver services that are not ‘one size fits all’ but in practice if you have dietary guidelines uniformly applied to everyone (sick and healthy) it really is lip service!
More importantly, when you get medically and metabolically tested, it is well apparent that your dietary, exercise and eating must be individualised to optimise your metabolic health and that it is likely to change over time. It is reprehensible that dietitians are not systematically identifying the people for whom a low carbohydrate diet is beneficial and helping them with an individualised journey.
It is a shame that you (dietetic associations) keep your members in the Dark Ages of dietetic practice. I suggest that if you don’t change then consumers should figure it out for themselves and vote with their feet.
Oh, that’s right. We are!
11 thoughts on “Engineering a Cure for Type 2 Diabetes: 18 Months”
Good to hear all going well, nothing on the blog that I can see re your weight I would assume you have lost a considerable amount. I am sorry that health messages are so mixed but correct nutrition will do huge amounts to reduce the epidemics of Obesity, type 2 Diabetes & Cancers.
Agree that a low Carb diet is a winner for type 2 Diabetics however it is both a curable but PREVENTABLE condition for the vast majority of sufferers. The long term message is control especially for the next generation, The long term effects (in years ) of a high fat / protein diet don’t appear as healthfull as say a Mediterranean diet which gives a lessening of the CHO restriction but not a free for all & don’t believe C2H5OH is needed for health. Retired medic who remains active & healthy
Thanks for your comments. It was mentioned that I lost 16Kgs but the good thing about carb restriction is that blood glucose regulation preceded most of that weight loss. If I was metabolically healthy I would head for the (proper) Mediterranean diet but definitely low on refined carbs. Alcohol is the fourth macro and the red one in my pyramid logo for a reason! To relieve the frustration from dietetic health messages one might have too much to drown one’s sorrows at present. I didn’t do well on a low-fat diet and it is curious that my blood lipids improved eating more saturated fat in the last year than I ate in the rest of my life!
Thanks so much for sharing your experience with low carb. All the best..
Thanks for reading.
I appreciated the study you did … n=1 is valid and the more of these added together make an enormous valid and convincing evidence. I am a CBC from South Africa. CBC is for Certified Banting Coach. I specialise in helping people with T2 Diabetes and those at risk of T2 Diabetes.
Blessings and Thank you for wonderfully written article and a systematic approach!!!
Thanks Yorke. I had to do this figuring a lot out myself but had some support on social media along the way. People do need help.
Enjoy it while you can… the South African Health regulatory body / SA Dieticians are having another attempt at muzzling Prof. Tim Noakes.
After their own ‘court’ found him innocent of various specious charges, they are – wait for it – appealing their OWN verdict !
Dieticians in Australia have already managed to muzzle Dr Fettke for suggesting his diabetic patients switch to Low carb / high fat approach, rather than “conventional” advice.
I lost nearly 30 kg over a year, HbA1C down to 5’s from 14. Same again, off all metformin, BP meds and normalized that as well.
– And ate a LOT of Himalayan Pink Salt …
In that case, I think you will find another one or two articles to enjoy here.
Hey M4. Fantastic results! Have you read Fung? I think some longer fasts are in order. Fasting is THE fastest way to get into ketosis, and once there, you can probably have some spaced-out protein-heavy meals and stay in ketosis.
Fung turned to fasting when even LCHF didn’t work for some patients. Virta does it without fasting, but they stay in ketosis. I think fasting is easier personally. Maybe try a 36, 48, or even a 60 hour fast… you might be surprised by how easy it is. I frequently do fasts of 36-60 hours and lately have even extended it to accelerate my weight loss. I don’t think I’ve lost much muscle at all, and energy is AWESOME. I’ve exercised fasted many times and I do fine. In fact, some swear by fasted exercise.
Peter Attia recently talked about “his toughest” patient, and his solution was 5 day fasts once a month for 3 months, plus IF keto the rest of the days. It worked great for him, it all turned around.
I really believe Fung is right on this, and Phinney is too cautious in prohibiting multi-day fasts. For some (like me) it really breaks through walls like nothing else. Just be sure to get your electrolytes (daily cup of bone broth with lots of salt plus Mg/K supplements do it for me).
Thanks. Yes I have Fung’s book. Longest fast I have done is 3 days. Coincidentally or not this was right at the point that I stalled so like Phinney, I am cautious about long fasts!